Friday, February 25, 2011

Current Event x3

LGBT groups demand retraction of Kan. student's homosexuality editorial


Summary:
When a student writes an article over a controversial subject, a small city flares into a dispute. An anti-gay student writes a Valentine's Day article stating that "these relationships just are not normal". The LGBT alliance had a problem with this article and spoke up about it. 


Although the conflict has not been resolved many of the Wichita citizens have spoken their own opinions regarding the publication of the article or not. Although the disputes have calmed down a bit there are still many questions for the entirety of the town.


Relation to 1st ammendment:
Many people are claiming freedom of speech should allow that article to be published. It's claimed that material should not be suppressed because of controversial matter and since that applies to this article it is believed by many that this was politically correct to publish.


However, many pro-gay students saw the article as harrassment and believe it should be censored. Also, it is stated that  it is High School administrators responsiblity to censor language that hurts students emotionally.

Kan. neighbors' feud sparks free-speech debate

Summary:
Between the Grebenik and the Vega family alone there is a hostile air all around the city. But this isn't only affecting them it's causing one family to move altogether. The Grebenik and Vega family have been fighting for months but only recently have they made it extremely personal. Grebenik claims Vega brought his family into it which is another issue for him.

Grebenik then put up disgraceful signs about the Vega faimly in his yard for the whole city to see. The city council says this is legal because they are on private property and don't contain profanity. However it seems to be Wichita v.s. Grebenik. Many of the citizens have complaints about him and his lifestyle. At this time there is no peaceful resolution.

Relation to 1st Amendment:
Although many people believe what Grebenik is doing is wrong, there is nothing to be done about it. He has his rights, and the right of free speech stands out particularly in this case. There is little to be done to stop him from posting signs in his yard.


Freedom of speech is on Grebenik's side and in which case it is nearly impossible to put an end to this feud.

U.S. Supreme Court: Will distress trump the First Amendment right to free speech?

Summary:
During a funeral for a dead soldier Fred Phelps and followers protested. Some signs were saying "God Hates You" while others were saying "Thank God For Dead Soldiers". Obviously, the grieving faimly had a problem with this. Albert Snyder, the deceased father, sued the church and its founder, Fred Phelps. The U.S. Supreme Court is having trouble deciding whether this is legal or not.


Relation to 1st Amendment:
No matter the place or the situation, what Phelps did is considered legal. Since the picketing was not specifically directed at Snyder, Phelps has the freedom of speech working on his side. However, even if this is legal, it is seen unethical by most.

No comments:

Post a Comment